By Albert Cai
2020 is shaping up to huge year in automated insulin delivery. Updates from DiabetesMine Innovation Summit’s first-ever closed loop showcase
The diaTribe team was on the ground at UCSF Mission Bay for DiabetesMine’s 2019 Innovation Summit, which featured updates on many of the new automated insulin delivery systems expected over the next few years. This list covers many of the most notable products coming soon. A more detailed description of each product follows the table of contents below. All descriptions and launch timelines reflect US availability.
Click to jump to a product, which are organized chronologically by their expected launch date.
The development of automated insulin delivery (AID) has many names – artificial pancreas, hybrid closed loop, Bionic Pancreas, predictive low glucose suspend – but all share the same goal: using continuous glucose monitors (CGMs) and smart algorithms that automatically adjust insulin delivery via pump. The goal of these products is to reduce/eliminate hypoglycemia, improve time in range, and reduce hyperglycemia – especially overnight.
When thinking about AID systems, it’s often helpful to think in stages.
Stage 1: The most basic AID system might shut off the insulin pump from delivering insulin whenever the user’s CGM readings drop below a certain number, such as 70 mg/dl, to prevent severe hypoglycemia.
Stage 2: The AID system could predict when glucose is going to go low and automatically reduce or stop insulin delivery.
Stage 3: The AID system may be able to automatically adjust basal insulin delivery depending on whether the user’s glucose is trending up or down. At this stage, the user would still have to manually give meal boluses and correction boluses.
Stage 4: The AID systems will be able to deliver correction boluses when glucose values are high.
Stage 5: The systems will be able to detect meals and automatically deliver the proper meal boluses to prevent high blood glucose. With elimination of manual meal bolusing, the system is said to become “fully closed loop.”
Currently available products are in stages 2-3. By the end of 2020, we may have multiple available systems at stage 4.
Now available for 14+ years.
What is it? Medtronic’s MiniMed 670G has been available since spring 2017 and was the first AID system to be FDA approved. The MiniMed 670G automatically adjusts basal insulin delivery every five minutes based on CGM readings, targeting a level of 120 mg/dl. The target glucose can also be temporarily raised to 150 mg/dl when low blood sugar (hypoglycemia) is a concern, such as during exercise. The MiniMed 670G comes with Medtronic’s Guardian CGM, which has seven-day wear and requires two-calibrations per day (although four are recommended). See our article from 2016 for a full breakdown on the MiniMed 670G.
Now available for 6+ years.
What is it? Tandem’s Basal-IQ has been available since August 2018 and uses Tandem’s t:slim X2 pump with Dexcom’s no-fingersticks G6 CGM. Basal-IQ is a predictive low glucose suspend system, meaning it will stop basal insulin delivery whenever glucose is predicted to be below 80 mg/dl within the next 30 minutes or when glucose is already below 70 mg/dl and falling. The system will automatically resume delivery whenever the user’s glucose levels begin to rise. Importantly, Basal-IQ was provided as a free at-home software update to in-warranty users of the t:slim X2 pump.
Currently under FDA review. Expected approval and launch in late 2019 for 14+ years.
What’s new? The highly anticipated Control-IQ will be a free software update for people using Tandem’s t:slim X2 pump with Dexcom’s no-fingersticks G6 CGM. Control-IQ will be the first system to bring automatic correction boluses: when it predicts glucose to be above 180 mg/dl in 30 minutes, the system will deliver 60% of the correction bolus needed to reach a target of 110 mg/dl. Control-IQ also includes automatic basal rate adjustments and will predictive insulin suspension (like Basal-IQ). Control-IQ targets glucose values between 112.5 and 160 mg/dl, though when Sleep Activity mode is on (users can either turn it on/off manually or set a sleep schedule), the system tightens the target range to achieve 112.5-120 mg/dl by the morning. A 168-person study of Control-IQ was presented at ADA 2019 (see diaTribe’s coverage) and showed time in range was 2.6 hours per day higher (70% vs. 59%) for those using Control-IQ vs. the same pump and CGM without Control-IQ. A1C was 0.3% lower with Control-IQ (7.1% vs. 7.4%).
How do I get it? When Control-IQ receives FDA approval, in-warranty t:slim X2 users will receive an email with a link to a website where they will be able to request a prescription for Control-IQ. When Tandem receives the prescription, it will send a link to an online training module and quiz that users will have to complete and pass. Then, they will receive a unique download code that can be used to update their pumps with Control-IQ. Note: this update process is subject to change, as Control-IQ is not yet FDA approved.
Pivotal trial currently underway, US launch likely in mid-2020 for adults first (14+ or 18+ years).
What’s new? MiniMed 780G will be Medtronic’s second AID system and a significant upgrade over MiniMed 670G. MiniMed 780G will include automatic correction boluses and an adjustable glucose target down to 100 mg/dl. The system will also have fewer alarms and simpler operation than the 670G. Medtronic is targeting an ambitious >80% time in range goal for 780G users. The 780G will also add Bluetooth connectivity to the pump, meaning users will be able to view pump data on their phones, upload pump data wirelessly, and update their pump wirelessly. MiniMed 780G will use the same Guardian CGM as 670G, which requires two fingersticks per day and has a seven-day wear time. The FDA is currently reviewing Guardian CGM for “non-adjunctive” use – if approved, this means that users will be able to deliver insulin boluses based on the CGM reading alone, without a confirmatory fingerstick.
Pivotal trial is expected to start in December, US launch planned for second half of 2020.
What’s new? Horizon is Insulet’s AID system for its popular Omnipod 3-day wear patch pumps. The system uses Dexcom’s G6 CGM and will likely be the first pump and AID system that users will be able to control directly from their smartphones. Smartphone control may be available for Android users first, though Insulet is also working with Tidepool (see below) on an iPhone offering. Horizon will have adjustable targets between 100 to 150 mg/dl. Because the Omnipod pump will store the algorithm and communicate directly with Dexcom G6, the system will work even when their smartphone/pump controller is not nearby.
Online observational study ongoing, launch timeline depends on FDA progress.
What’s new? Unlike the others in this list, Tidepool is a non-profit and is working on the AID algorithm only (in other words, Tidepool does not have its own insulin pump). About one year ago, Tidepool announced its plans to submit the do-it-yourself (DIY) Loop app to the FDA as an officially supported app available on the Apple app store. Loop is an open-source (free and publicly available, like Wikipedia), non-FDA-approved AID system that is compatible with Dexcom and Medtronic CGMs and old Medtronic and Insulet pumps. Read about Adam’s experience using DIY Loop here. Tidepool plans to get Loop approved by the FDA, available on the App Store, and work with in-warranty, commercially available pumps and CGMs. Currently, Tidepool has partnerships with Insulet, Dexcom, and Medtronic. An large, completely virtual study is ongoing for Loop users and the data will support Tidepool’s submission of Loop to the FDA. To differentiate Tidepool Loop from the DIY-version, Tidepool Loop will have different colors, guardrails around certain settings, and a built-in tutorial for new users. Much of what Tidepool is doing is unprecedented, so the launch timing is unclear. CEO Howard Look said at Friends for Life 2019, “We never want to be the company that contributes to mis-set expectations (like ‘a cure in five years’), so we want to keep expectations low. We hope it’s measured in months, not years. We let the FDA know that we set an aggressive target of trying to have a submission prepared before the end of the (calendar) year, but there’s a lot that’s out of our control, so that’s just an estimate. We promise to keep the community up to speed as things proceed.”
Looking beyond 2020, we will see further advanced in AID systems, including the first dual-hormone (insulin + glucagon) systems.
Beta Bionics iLet: The iLet pump will work with insulin-only or insulin + glucagon and Dexcom or Senseonics’ CGMs. Only body weight needs to be entered at set up (no insulin-to-carb ratio, sensitivity factor, etc.) and the system will learn over time. Users will not need to count carbs, only describe meals as containing more, less, or the same amount of carbs as usual to bolus. The FDA submission for the insulin-only version could come in late 2020/early 2021.
Lilly: Lilly has not shared much on its hybrid closed loop system, but diaTribe got to hold a prototype back in 2018. The white, disk-shaped pump is about two inches across, and can be worn as a patch, with a short infusion set, or slipped into a pocket with a longer infusion set. The pump will communicate directly with Dexcom G6 and could launch with smartphone control. Lilly has never shared many details on its launch timing, though this system could come sometime in 2020-2021.
Bigfoot Biomedical: Bigfoot Biomedical’s AID system, formerly called Loop, will use the FreeStyle Libre CGM, a screenless pump, and a smartphone app for control. This system may not launch until 2023.