Google Home Hub vs Amazon Echo Show


The $230 Amazon Echo Show sounds great when it plays music. The $150 Google Home Hub makes your personal pictures look fantastic in ambient mode. The flagship smart displays from two tech giants look very different — the Echo Show dwarfs the Home Hub in size — but they serve a lot of the same purposes.

Both smart displays respond to the same voice commands as an ordinary smart speaker like the Amazon Echo or the Google Home. Both use a screen to show extra info when you ask a question. You see a detailed forecast when you ask about the weather, or you can browse pics of a restaurant if you’re looking for a place to eat. You can also use the screen on both devices to watch videos, control smart home devices, make video calls and check on the feed from your security cam.

Both of these devices have been out awhile, which means they’re well-established by now. So it’s a good time to figure out, once and for all, which company makes the better smart display.

Read moreThe Amazon Echo Show 5 is Alexa’s best smart display

We’re here to help you make informed purchase decisions. If you use our links to buy, we may get a commission.

Chris Monroe/CNET

The Amazon Echo Show and Google Home Hub each house a digital assistant: Alexa and Google Assistant. These assistants have their strengths and weaknesses. Alexa, for instance, works with a wider variety of devices and sports more features, whereas Google responds more intuitively to commands. Despite a pretty even split here, though, the Google Home Hub boasts enough distinctive features to make it our recommendation for a smart display.

First, Google’s display manages a large number of smart home gadgets more elegantly, organizing them into an easy-to-understand control panel for touch controls. Organization goes a long way, it seems, as the cooking assistance offered by the Home Hub (step-by-step recipes, simultaneous music and video streaming, etc.) gains a slight edge over the Echo Show for its intuitive interface.

Speaking of streaming video, the Echo Show boasts a significantly larger display than Google’s (10 inches vs. 7 inches), but it’s hard to beat the presence of YouTube (owned by Google) on the Home Hub. Finally, a few nice design touches, such as how the Home Hub adapts the brightness and warmth of the photos it displays to match the room, really bring together Google’s product as the more aesthetically pleasing device.

Since the two devices are close on most fronts, you should go with the Amazon Echo Show if you prefer Alexa. You should also go with the Echo Show if you want a smart display that sounds good when playing music. However, if you’re a Google fan or if you’re on the fence, the Google Home Hub is the better choice.

It costs less, and it’s better at controlling your smart home, walking you through recipes and showing your personal pictures. You probably don’t need your smart display to be your main screen for watching TV or your main speaker for listening to music. Smart displays are best at showing you what you need to know to keep your hands free in the kitchen. The Google Home Hub is great at that, and it’s the better smart display as a result.

Tyler Lizenby/CNET

The Amazon Echo Show is much bigger than the Google Home Hub, so some discrepancy in sound quality is understandable, but it’s a big gap. The Echo Show sounds great — on par with full sized smart speakers like the Amazon Echo. The Home Hub has trouble matching even small smart speakers like the Google Home Mini in sound quality.

Unlike speakers, though, the microphone hardware of the Home Hub puts up a good fight. Both displays use microphones well and will generally hear your commands from across a large room. The Echo Show still beats Google slightly as it more frequently can hear commands from an adjacent room and over background noise.

Of course, at the end of the day, the Google Home Hub has no camera, which means only one-way video chat. Add full video chat to the Show’s 10-inch screen, and you have clear winner. If you’re looking for a smart display to use for video chat, the Echo Show is the only pick. Of course, with no shutter to cover the Echo Show’s camera, and mounting anxiety about privacy issues and facial recognition technology, not everyone will opt for the Show.

Now playing:
Watch this:

The battle for the best smart display: Google Home Hub…


The Google Home Hub

Best all‑around smart display

Amazon Echo Show

Better for video and voice chat

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here